Story Idea Triage
A scoring sheet and AI first pass for the pile of story ideas a comms team accumulates: sort them by audience value, angle strength and effort, and decide which get made, which get parked and which get a polite no.
Keep in mind Scores are a guide based only on what you give the AI, so check that proof is really in hand and that consent or sign-off is confirmed before anything is commissioned.
Version 1.1 · Updated 30 October 2026
What you'll get
The opening of a worked example. Anonymised and shortened; yours will follow your inputs.
Fictional example: a university comms team. All ideas and figures are invented.
Period: October 2026. Capacity: six pieces, two substantial. Themes: widening access; flexible study.
| # | Idea | Requester | Aud. | Angle | Fit | Time | Proof | Effort | Total | Decision | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Student volunteers helped 300 local pupils with reading | Widening participation team | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 15 | Park | Strongest outcome story we have, but the school and parents have not agreed to be named; revisit when consent is confirmed |
| 2 | Staff charity bake sale | Estates office | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 11 | Decline | Staff newsletter and a photo; not a story for external channels |
| 3 | Vice-chancellor at the sector conference | Vice-chancellor's office | 2 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 12 | Merge | The story is the talk, if it makes the flexible-study argument. Merge with #6 |
Commissioned: #5 (substantial, report plus social), #3 and #6 as one piece (conference talk plus explainer), plus three from the standing plan. Parked: #1, until consent is confirmed; #4, January 2027. Declined: #2, with the staff newsletter offered.
Next step
The prompt ends with questions for you. Answer them with this, in the same chat.
Here are my answers to your questions: [YOUR ANSWERS] Revise the draft using them. Remove the [Assumed] and [Confirm] marks my answers resolve, keep the rest, and update the questions and checks.
Human review checklist
Go deeper
Variations
One idea from someone senior
Use this when a single idea has come from a senior colleague and you need to answer it well.
Instead of a batch, I have one idea from a senior colleague: [THEIR ROLE, AND THE IDEA AS THEY PUT IT]. Score it on the six criteria and find its strongest angle. If it is weak, say so plainly and why. Then draft two replies I can choose between: one that commissions it in its strongest form and says what material I need from them, and one that parks or declines it with a reason and an alternative. Neither reply should promise coverage, timing or results we cannot control.Finding the pattern in past ideas
Use this when you want to improve the ideas you receive, not score a new batch.
Instead of scoring a new batch, look back at past ideas and the decisions made on them: [THE IDEAS, REQUESTERS AND DECISIONS, AND THE PERIOD THEY COVER]. Tell me which teams send the strongest ideas, which criteria fail most often, which themes are over-supplied and which under-supplied against our key messages, and one change to how we take in ideas that would improve the next batch. Base every finding on the list, and where the list is too short to show a pattern, say so.Full example output
Example output
Anonymised and shortened. Real outputs will vary based on your inputs.
Fictional example: a university comms team. All ideas and figures are invented.
Period: October 2026. Capacity: six pieces, two substantial. Themes: widening access; flexible study.
| # | Idea | Requester | Aud. | Angle | Fit | Time | Proof | Effort | Total | Decision | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Student volunteers helped 300 local pupils with reading | Widening participation team | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 15 | Park | Strongest outcome story we have, but the school and parents have not agreed to be named; revisit when consent is confirmed |
| 2 | Staff charity bake sale | Estates office | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 11 | Decline | Staff newsletter and a photo; not a story for external channels |
| 3 | Vice-chancellor at the sector conference | Vice-chancellor’s office | 2 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 12 | Merge | The story is the talk, if it makes the flexible-study argument. Merge with #6 |
| 4 | New head of library services profile | HR | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 12 | Park | Runs better with the library reopening; revisit January 2027 |
| 5 | Survey: 62% of applicants want evening open days | Admissions insight team | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 16 | Make | Our own survey of 1,400 applicants, report in hand; the number carries it. Substantial piece |
| 6 | New part-time degree explainer | Academic registry | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 15 | Merge | Combine with #3: the explainer is the talk’s content, the talk is the hook |
Commissioned: #5 (substantial, report plus social), #3 and #6 as one piece (conference talk plus explainer), plus three from the standing plan. Parked: #1, until consent is confirmed; #4, January 2027. Declined: #2, with the staff newsletter offered.
The template
Triage header
Period: [e.g. October 2026] Capacity: [e.g. six pieces, two of them substantial] Themes we are building: [Two or three] Audiences: [List]
Scoring sheet
Score each criterion 1 to 3 (low, medium, high). Treat the total as a guide and make the decision yourself.
| # | Idea | Requester | Audience value | Angle strength | Message fit | Timeliness | Proof available | Effort (3 = low) | Total | Decision | Reason | Reply sent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | [Idea] | [Name] | Make / Merge / Park / Decline | [One line] | Yes / No |
Criteria
- Audience value: would a named audience read, share or act on this? 3 means a clear audience with a clear reason.
- Angle strength: is there a tension, a change, a first, a number or a person at the centre? 3 means the angle writes itself.
- Message fit: does it advance a key message or a theme we are building?
- Timeliness: is there a reason to run it now, or a hook it could attach to?
- Proof available: do we have the data, the spokesperson, the case study, the images? 3 means in hand.
- Effort: how much work to make it well? Score inversely, so low effort scores 3.
Decisions
| Decision | Meaning | What happens next |
|---|---|---|
| Make | Goes into the plan for this period | Added to the content calendar with an owner and a format |
| Merge | Combines with another idea into one stronger story | Both requesters told; the combined story goes to Make |
| Park | Good idea, wrong time or missing proof | Logged with what would unlock it and a date to revisit |
| Decline | Not for us, or not now and unlikely later | Requester told, with the reason and any alternative (an internal channel, another organisation’s channel) |
Replies
Make: “Yes. We will run this as [format] in [period]. I need [material] from you by [date].” Merge: “Yes, combined with [other idea], which makes it stronger because [reason]. [Name] is also involved.” Park: “Not this period. It needs [proof / hook / spokesperson] first. I have logged it to revisit on [date].” Decline: “Not one for our channels, because [reason]. [Alternative, if any].”
When to use it
What it is
Story ideas arrive from everywhere: a product manager’s launch, the CEO’s conference, a colleague’s charity run, a customer who said something nice. Without a consistent way to choose, decisions can end up with whoever asked most recently or most loudly. This template is a triage sheet: each idea is scored on a handful of criteria, given a decision, and either scheduled, parked with a reason or declined with a reply the requester can accept.
AI does the first pass, categorising the batch, proposing the strongest angle for each idea and flagging where two ideas could be one story. You make the calls and own the replies. By the end you have a ranked list, a short set of decisions and a record you can point to the next time someone asks why their story did not run.
When to use it
Use this template when:
- The story backlog has more than a handful of items and is growing
- You are building next month’s content plan and need to choose
- Requesters are getting inconsistent answers, or no answer
- An idea seems weak but the requester matters and you want to find the angle before saying no
- Two or three teams have suggested overlapping stories
Don’t use this template if:
- You have one idea and need to develop it; use the Media Pitch Builder or the Blog Post Outline Pack
- The stories are already commissioned and the question is scheduling; that is the Content Calendar
- The decision is political and needs a conversation with the people involved
Inputs needed
Before starting, gather:
- Who your organisation is, and the period you are planning, with the year
- The ideas, one line each, with the requester, the date suggested and any material offered (data, a spokesperson, images)
- Your audience profiles, or at least a list of audiences and what each wants from you
- The current content plan, with the gaps and the themes you are trying to build
- Your key messages
- Your capacity for the period: how many pieces the team can make well
Tips for success
Score before you argue.
The sheet gives everyone the same language. A requester who can see their idea scored 1 on angle strength may find the angle themselves.
Look for the merge.
A strong story can come from two weak ideas that share a hook. Ask the AI pass to look for it explicitly.
Say no with a reason and a door.
A decline that names the criterion and offers an alternative helps keep ideas coming. Silence can stop them.
Track the parked list.
Parked without a revisit date is declined without the courtesy. Put the date in the calendar.
Review the batch as well as the ideas.
Every quarter, look at who suggests what and which criteria fail most. That tells you where to coach and where to change the intake form.
Common pitfalls
Letting the total decide.
A 15 with no proof available is a 15 you cannot make this month. Read the whole row before you look at the total.
Scoring effort first.
Easy stories can crowd out good ones. Score audience value and angle before you look at effort.
Confusing a topic with a story.
“Our sustainability work” is a topic. “We cut fleet emissions by a third and it cost less than we expected” is a story. If the AI pass cannot find the angle, the idea is a topic.
Ignoring internal channels.
Some declined ideas make good internal stories. Route them to those channels.
Pasting sensitive detail into a tool.
Story ideas can carry unannounced launches, customer names and figures. Follow your AI Use Policy and strip what should not travel before scoring.
Related templates
Monthly Content Calendar Planner
A 30-day content planning tool that maps themes, content types, and distribution channels across a full month.
Content Repurposing Matrix
A framework for turning one report, webinar or article into pieces for other formats and channels, keeping every finding and caveat accurate.
Comms Audience Profile
A one-page audience profile that helps communications professionals understand who they are communicating with before they start writing, planning, or pitching, covering role context, motivations, barriers, and communication preferences.
Key Messages Grid
Audience-specific message variants that systematically adapt core messages for different personas, channels, and contexts whilst maintaining strategic consistency.
Media Pitch Builder
A structured approach to writing media pitches, with angle variants for news, features, comment, and exclusive stories.