Skip to main content
35 minutes Intermediate Strategise

Competitor Comms Audit

Analyse how competitors or peer organisations communicate: their messaging, channels, tone and narrative positioning, so you can identify gaps and sharpen your own strategy.

Keep in mind The audit is only as good as the copy you gather: the AI works from what you paste, so a channel you have not reviewed stays blank rather than guessed.

Version 1.1 · Updated 30 October 2026

What you'll get

The opening of a worked example. Anonymised and shortened; yours will follow your inputs.

Fictional example: all four organisations are invented.

Audit scope: Three peer mental health charities, compared by a fourth (Wrenfold Mental Health Trust). Websites for all three peers; LinkedIn for Peers A and B. July to September 2026.

Peer A leads with clinical expertise: "evidence-based support" appears on every service page; formal tone; case studies cite outcome data. Most active on LinkedIn with research summaries. Strength: credibility with commissioners. Weakness: little in plain language for people looking for help.

Peer B emphasises speed of access: "talk to someone today" is the homepage headline; conversational tone; many short how-to posts. Engagement: not reviewed. Strength: accessible. Weakness: few proof points.

See the full example

Next step

The prompt ends with questions for you. Answer them with this, in the same chat.

Here are my answers to your questions: [YOUR ANSWERS]

Revise the draft using them. Remove the [Assumed] and [Confirm] marks my answers resolve, keep the rest, and update the questions and checks.

Human review checklist

Go deeper

Variations

Quick scan

Use this when you need a short comparison before a meeting rather than a full audit.

Instead of sections 2 to 6, give one table with the columns Organisation | Core message (one sentence) | Tone (two words) | Most visible channel | Main communications strength, with a row for us, then two sentences on the clearest gap. Base every cell on the material I have pasted, and say this is a first read, not an audit.

Moving into a new area

Use this when you are starting to communicate in a sector, region or topic that is new to you.

We are starting to communicate in [THE NEW SECTOR, REGION OR TOPIC], about [WHAT WE ARE OFFERING OR SAYING THERE]. After section 6, add a section "Conventions in this space": how organisations here typically talk; the conventions we should follow to be credible with this audience; any we could break to stand out, with the risk of doing so; and what the material suggests the audience expects. Keep what the material shows separate from your interpretation.

Full example output

Example output

Anonymised and shortened. Real outputs will vary based on your inputs.

Fictional example: all four organisations are invented.

Audit scope: Three peer mental health charities, compared by a fourth (Wrenfold Mental Health Trust). Websites for all three peers; LinkedIn for Peers A and B. July to September 2026.

Peer A leads with clinical expertise: “evidence-based support” appears on every service page; formal tone; case studies cite outcome data. Most active on LinkedIn with research summaries. Strength: credibility with commissioners. Weakness: little in plain language for people looking for help.

Peer B emphasises speed of access: “talk to someone today” is the homepage headline; conversational tone; many short how-to posts. Engagement: not reviewed. Strength: accessible. Weakness: few proof points.

Peer C leads with lived experience: most content is first-person stories from volunteers. Warm, community tone. Website only; LinkedIn not reviewed. Strength: distinctive voice. Weakness: unclear what services it offers.

Gap identified (hypothesis): None of the three talks about what happens while people wait for support. This may be unclaimed because it is uncomfortable to discuss, or because the audience does not look for it. Worth testing with service users before Wrenfold builds messages around it.

Note: This is an illustrative example. Your audit will reflect your specific sector and competitors.


The template

Audit scope

FieldDetails
Date of audit
Competitors reviewed
Channels reviewed
Time period covered(e.g., last 90 days)
Conducted by

Organisation profile: [Name]

Complete one block per organisation.

Core messaging

ElementObservation
Primary headline / taglineWhat is the single line they lead with?
PromiseWhat do they claim to deliver for the people they serve?
Target audienceWho are they speaking to, explicitly or implicitly?
Key proof pointsWhat evidence or credentials do they use?
Call to actionWhat do they most commonly ask people to do?

Tone and voice

ElementObservation
Overall tone(e.g., authoritative, conversational, aspirational, cautious)
Formality level(Formal / Semi-formal / Informal)
Use of jargonHeavy / moderate / minimal
Personality traits3 words that describe how they sound
Notable language patternsPhrases or words they repeat consistently

Channel activity

List only the channels you reviewed. Where you have no figures, write “Not reviewed” for frequency or engagement rather than guessing.

ChannelActive?FrequencyContent typesEngagement level
[Channel reviewed]Yes / No
[Channel reviewed]Yes / No
[Channel reviewed]Yes / No

Narrative and themes

What three or four overarching themes does this organisation return to repeatedly?

ThemeHow they address itFrequency

Strengths and weaknesses (comms only)

StrengthsWeaknesses

Competitive landscape summary

After completing individual profiles, complete the summary view:

Messaging map

OrganisationCore claimPrimary audienceDominant toneMost active channel
[Name]
[Name]
[Name]
Your organisation

Narrative territory map

For each theme below, indicate which competitors are claiming it (and how strongly):

Theme / territoryWho owns itHow stronglyIs it contested?
[Innovation / being first]
[Trust / credibility / heritage]
[Community / people]
[Value / efficiency]
[Purpose / impact]
[Add your own]

Gap analysis

Where is the narrative space that the organisations you reviewed are NOT occupying?

Gap identifiedWhy it’s unclaimed (hypothesis)Opportunity for you?
Yes / No / Maybe

Your positioning assessment

QuestionYour assessment
Where do you currently sit in the landscape?
Are you clearly differentiated?Yes / Somewhat / No
Whose narrative most overlaps yours?
Which territory could you credibly hold?
What one thing should you change about your messaging based on this audit?

When to use it

What it is

The Competitor Comms Audit is a structured framework for analysing how your key competitors or peer organisations communicate: what they say, where they say it, how they say it, and what narrative they’re building. This template focuses specifically on communications: messaging, tone, channel choices, content types, and narrative positioning.

By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of where competitors are active and vocal, what messages they’re leading with, where gaps exist in the wider narrative, and how your own positioning stacks up. It is a useful input to campaign planning, a rebrand or a strategy refresh.

When to use it

Use this template when:

  • Planning a campaign in a crowded field where positioning matters
  • Refreshing your comms strategy and wanting an external reference point
  • Onboarding a new communications agency and they need competitive context
  • A competitor or peer organisation has made a significant announcement or shifted their narrative
  • You’re entering a new market or audience segment and want to understand the communications landscape

Don’t use this template when:

  • You need a full commercial competitive analysis (pricing, product features, market share): this is comms-specific
  • There are no comparable organisations whose communications you can review
  • You’re looking at media coverage rather than owned channel communications (use the Monitoring & Reporting templates instead)

Inputs needed

Before starting, gather:

  • A shortlist of three to five competitors or peer organisations (be selective: depth beats breadth here)
  • The channels and period you will review (for example website and LinkedIn, last 90 days)
  • Copy and notes from each organisation’s channels, with dates: pages, posts, press releases, reports
  • Your own current key messages or positioning statement for comparison
  • Optional: media monitoring reports or share-of-voice data

Tips for success

Narrow your competitor list deliberately

A long list of competitors can produce an unusable report. Choose three to five: your two or three closest direct competitors, and one aspirational benchmark from outside your immediate category. This keeps the audit actionable.

Focus on patterns across pieces

One LinkedIn post doesn’t define a messaging strategy. Look for what they return to repeatedly: the themes, phrases, and claims that show up across multiple channels and multiple months. Patterns reveal strategy; one-offs reveal opportunism.

Separate observation from interpretation

Complete the observation sections before drawing conclusions. Premature interpretation can lead you to find evidence for what you already believe. The gap analysis is more valuable when built on clean data.

Include yourself in the audit

The most useful output is a map that includes your own organisation. Auditing competitors without plotting yourself against them misses half the value. Be honest about where you’re actually differentiated versus where you’re saying similar things with different words.

Revisit quarterly

Competitor communications evolve. A campaign launch, leadership change, or crisis response can shift an organisation’s narrative significantly. A quarterly light-touch update covering key channels only can be more useful than an annual deep dive.

Common pitfalls

Confusing aspiration with reality

Competitors’ owned channels show how they want to be perceived, which may differ from how they are perceived. A bold brand positioning statement on a website doesn’t mean audiences have absorbed or accepted that narrative. Where possible, sense-check competitor messaging claims against external sources (media coverage, public reviews, social comments).

Over-weighting surface-level differences

Two competitors may use completely different design aesthetics and still be saying essentially the same thing. Focus on the underlying message and claim as well as the visual or tonal execution. Real differentiation comes from what you’re saying as much as how you look.

Ignoring channel absence as a signal

A competitor who is conspicuously absent from a high-activity channel may have tried and failed there, or may simply not have the resource. Their absence is data, but don’t assume it signals an open opportunity without understanding why they’re not there.

Using the audit to confirm existing decisions

The competitor comms audit is most valuable when it challenges your assumptions. If you complete it and find it simply confirms that your current strategy is right, check whether you have been too generous with your own positioning and too critical of competitors’. Push yourself to find at least one thing that makes you reconsider.

Related templates

Audience Segmentation Worksheet

Define, profile, and prioritise distinct audience segments to tailor communications and allocate resources effectively.

Strategise

23 minutes · Straightforward

Campaign Brief

A comprehensive campaign planning document that aligns stakeholders on objectives, strategy, creative direction, and execution before work begins.

Strategise

28 minutes · Intermediate

Channel Strategy Matrix

Map messages to optimal channels with strategic rationale based on audience behaviour and campaign objectives.

Strategise

24 minutes · Intermediate

Positioning Statement Generator

Core positioning articulation that systematically defines target audience, category, key differentiation, and supporting proof to create a clear, defensible position with the people you serve.

Strategise

24 minutes · Intermediate